Homemade Isnt a Hall Pass: The Case for Smarter Pet Nutrition

The study found that healthy adult dogs fed a homemade diet modeled after the typical 'Western' human diet experienced significant gut imbalances, inflammation, and metabolic disruptions, all without gaining a single pound. 
 

Researchers examined the effects of a Western-style diet high in saturated fats and refined carbohydrates and low in fiber on ten clinically healthy, lean adult beagles. The researchers designed the diet to mimic common dietary patterns found in humans living in developed countries. Over three months, the dogs were first fed a high-fiber diet, then switched to a Western-style diet, and finally returned to their original, high-fiber diet. The results were striking. Despite maintaining ideal body weight and condition scores, the dogs exhibited signs of gut inflammation, unhealthy changes in gut bacteria, increased cell stress, and issues with how their bodies processed and digested their food. 
 

You could be interested

Experts Weigh In: Should Pet Owners Be Worried About Taurine?

Healthy Looking Doesn't Always Mean Healthy Eating 

These outcomes highlight two essential truths: health is not just about what's visible on the outside, and homemade does not inherently mean healthy. Internal dysfunction can exist even in pets that appear perfectly healthy.  
 

This isn't the first study to demonstrate how misleading appearances can be. In earlier research, homemade diets were evaluated for their nutritional adequacy and found to be lacking in one or more essential nutrients in nearly every instance. Common deficiencies included calcium, zinc, iron, and B vitamins, all of which are necessary for long-term health, but are often overlooked when owners prepare meals based on personal preference or online recipes. 
 

The assumption that 'fresh' equals 'better' often leads well-meaning owners to prepare meals for their pets at home. The popularity of home-cooked and raw diets has soared in recent years, driven by concerns over commercial pet food recalls and a desire for greater control over ingredients. However, nutritionists caution that homemade diets, when not professionally formulated, are frequently nutritionally imbalanced. Even recipes published in books or recommended by breeders commonly lack adequate levels of critical nutrients like calcium and vitamin D. 
 

How Diet Alone Can Disrupt a Dog's Gut and Health 

What makes this recent study particularly eye-opening is that it didn't just look at what was in the dogs' food; it also measured how their bodies responded to it.  
 

Dogs fed a Western-style diet showed clear signs of inflammation throughout their bodies. Their blood contained higher levels of markers associated with inflammation and cell stress, and their gut tissues showed signs of irritation and damage at the cellular level. These changes occurred even though the dogs were lean and appeared perfectly healthy on the outside. However, when they were transitioned back to the original high-fiber diet, many of those negative effects began to reverse. This indicated that the diet, not weight gain or illness, was responsible for the inflammation and gut issues. 
 

The gut is often referred to as the body's 'second brain,' and in this study, it played a significant role. When the dogs were fed the Western-style diet, the balance of bacteria in their digestive systems changed in unhealthy ways. There was an increase in bacteria associated with inflammation and digestive issues, along with a decrease in beneficial bacteria that help maintain the gut lining and produce essential nutrients. These changes in gut bacteria closely resemble what scientists observe in humans who consume a high-fat, low-fiber diet. It's another indication that diet quality can rapidly affect gut health, even in dogs, and that what we feed them is just as important as it is for us. 
 

One of the major differences between the two diets in the study was their fiber content, and it turns out that this made a major impact. Fiber is a key ingredient when it comes to gut health. It nourishes the beneficial bacteria in the digestive tract, which produce helpful compounds that reduce inflammation and promote a healthy gut lining. However, many homemade diets, particularly those that mimic high-protein, low-carb human trends, often lack sufficient fiber. One study found that even recipes created by veterinarians frequently did not include the appropriate types of fiber. The recent Western diet study further supported this, revealing that dogs on the low-fiber Western diet had more unhealthy bacteria in their digestive tracts and experienced negative changes in how their bodies processed and digested the food they were consuming. 
 

Another important finding from the study was how the diet impacted the dogs' bile acids (natural chemicals that help break down fat). Normally, bile acids are carefully regulated by the gut and its microbes. However, in dogs consuming the Western-style diet, levels of a particular type known as cholic acid significantly increased. Excessive amounts of this acid can irritate the gut lining. This imbalance, known as bile acid dysmetabolism, has been linked to gut inflammation in dogs and humans. Observing this condition in otherwise healthy dogs solely due to diet underscores how quickly poor nutrition can disrupt essential systems in the body. 
 

Do As I Say, Not As I Do 

Ultimately, the findings from this study urge us to reconsider how we define 'healthy' when it comes to pet nutrition. Lean body condition is important, yes, but it is not enough. If the diet fueling that lean body is rich in saturated fats and low in fiber and micronutrients, it may be quietly laying the groundwork for future disease. And if the dog's gut is inflamed, its immune system compromised, or its microbial balance disrupted, then we are failing our pets, even if they look 'fine.' 
 

This study challenges the conventional wisdom that a dog's outward appearance is a sufficient measure of health. Many owners assume that as long as their dog maintains a healthy weight, all is well. This research, however, shows that diet composition—not just calorie count—can greatly impact internal health, even in dogs that seem outwardly healthy. It also reinforces the limitations of do-it-yourself nutrition. Homemade diets are only as good as their formulation. Without careful nutrient analysis and professional guidance, they risk being incomplete, imbalanced, and biologically harmful over time. 
 

Of course, this does not mean that all homemade diets are bad. When properly formulated, home-prepared meals can be an excellent choice for pets with specific needs or owners who wish for more control over the ingredients. The key lies in precision, not guesswork. Creating balanced recipes requires nutritional software, ingredient databases, and a deep understanding of species-specific needs—resources that are not commonly available to the average pet owner. 
 

Why Leading Fresh Food Brands Rely on BSM Partners 

That's where we come in. In today's pet food landscape, where fresh, homemade-style diets are in high demand, nutritional precision is not just a bonus; it's a necessity. At BSM Partners, we bridge the gap between great ideas and scientifically sound execution. Our team of veterinary nutritionists, formulators, and microbiome experts work hand in hand with fresh food brands to ensure every recipe is not only complete-and-balanced, but also designed to support long-term wellness. We go far beyond basic nutrient targets; we create diets that align with how a pet's body actually responds to food. 
 

Whether entering the market or refining an existing product, partnering with BSM Partners ensures that your brand benefits from rigorous science, regulatory expertise, and a deep understanding of how ingredients interact with biology. In a space where consumer trust hinges on real results, BSM Partners is not just a partner—we are your competitive edge. 
 

About the Author
Neeley Bowden is a Manager of Special Services on the BSM Partners Product Innovation team. She earned her bachelor's degree in pet food production and her master's in food science. In her early career, she worked in product innovation of pet food ingredients, focusing on the development of palatability enhancers. Bowden calls her horse farm in South Carolina home, along with her faithful canine, Allie. 


By Neeley Bowden
Source: BSM Parnters